January 2013:
- The Missing Manuscript of Jane Austen–Syrie James
- Read and Buried–Erika Chase (Ashton Corners Book Club Mystery #2)
- A Death in the Small Hours–Charles Finch (Charles Lenox Mystery #6)
- The Midwife’s Tale–Sam Thomas
- Dial C For Chihuahua–Waverly Curtis (Barking Detective Mystery #1)
- The Borgia Mistress–Sara Poole (Poisoner Mystery #3)
- Mistress of My Fate–Hallie Rubenhold (Confessions of Henrietta Lightfoot #1)
- The Twelve Clues of Christmas–Rhys Bowen (Royal Spyness Mystery #6)
- The Last Runaway–Tracy Chevalier
- The Aviator’s Wife–Melanie Benjamin
- The Passing Bells–Phillip Rock (Greville Family Saga #1)
- The Bughouse Affair–Marcia Muller & Bill Pronzini (Carpenter and Quincannon Mystery #1)
- Summerset Abbey–T. J. Brown (Summerset Abbey #1)
- Parlor Games–Maryka Biaggio
- Speaking From Among the Bones–Alan Bradley (Flavia de Luce Mystery #5)
- Mrs. Lincoln’s Dressmaker–Jennifer Chiaverini
February 2013:
- The Anatomist’s Apprentice–Tessa Harris (Dr. Thomas Silkstone Mystery #1)
- The Long Quiche Goodbye–Avery Aames (Cheese Shop Mystery #1)
- Habits of the House–Fay Weldon (Love & Inheritance #1)
- A Medal for Murder–Frances Brody (Kate Shackleton Mystery #2)
- The Ambassador’s Daughter–Pam Jenoff
- A Plain Scandal–Amanda Flower (Appleseed Creek Mystery #2)
- The Kommandant’s Girl–Pam Jenoff
- The House at Riverton–Kate Morton
- Due or Die–Jenn McKinlay (Library Lover’s Mystery #2)
- Book, Line, and Sinker–Jenn McKinlay (Library Lover’s Mystery #3)
- Shadow on the Crown–Patricia Bracewell
- The Winter Witch–Paula Brackston (Witch #2)
- Death Drops–Chrystle Fiedler (Natural Remedies Mystery #1)
- India Black and the Shadows of Anarchy–Carol K. Carr (Madam of Espionage Mystery #3)
March 2013:
- Scent to Kill–Chrystle Fiedler (Natural Remedies Mystery #2)
- Town in a Pumpkin Bash–B.B. Haywood (Candy Holliday Mystery #4)
- Children of Liberty–Paullina Simons (Bronze Horseman Prequel)
- Etiquette & Espionage–Gail Carriger (Finishing School #1)
- The India Fan–Victoria Holt
- Glamorous Illusions–Lisa T. Bergren (Grand Tour #1)
- Grave Consequences–Lisa T. Bergren (Grand Tour #2)
- The House Girl–Tara Conklin
- Buried In a Bog–Sheila Connolly (County Cork Mystery #1)
- Every Trick In the Book–Lucy Arlington (Novel Idea Mystery #2)
- Shadows and Strongholds–Elizabeth Chadwick
April 2013:
- That Old Flame of Mine–J. J. Cook (Sweet Pepper Fire Brigade Mystery #1)
- Frankie’s Letter–Dolores Gordon-Smith
- Sketch Me If You Can–Sharon Pape (Portrait of Crime Mystery #1)
- To Sketch a Thief–Sharon Pape (Portrait of Crime Mystery #2)
- A Murder at Rosamund’s Gate–Susanna Calkins
- Lady of Ashes–Christine Trent
- The Fate of Mercy Alban–Wendy Webb
May 2013:
- Peach Pies and Alibis–Ellery Adams (Charmed Pie Shoppe Mystery #2)
- Assaulted Pretzel–Laura Bradford (Amish Mystery #2)
- Death of a Dowager–Joanna Campbell-Slan (Jane Eyre Chronicles #2)
- Topped Chef–Lucy Burdette (Key West Food Critic Mystery #3)
- Nickeled and Dimed To Death–Denise Swanson (Devereaux’s Dime Store Mystery #2)
- The Turncoat: Renegades of the Revolution–Donna Thorland (Renegades of the Revolution #1)
- The Ashford Affair–Lauren Willig
- One Hot Murder–Lorraine Bartlett (Victoria Square Murder #3)
- The Great Gatsby–F. Scott Fitzgerald
- The Highbury Murders–Victoria Grossack
- The Christie Curse–Victoria Abbott (Book Collector Mystery #1)
- Inferno–Dan Brown (Robert Langdon #4)
- A Broth of Betrayal–Connie Archer (Soup Lover’s Mystery #2)
June 2013:
- Blood & Beauty–Sarah Dunant
- The Family Way–Rhys Bowen (Molly Murphy Mystery #12)
- Murder in Chelsea–Victoria Thompson (Gaslight Mystery #15)
- An Inquiry into Love and Death–Simone St. James
- Chihuahua Confidential–Waverly Curtis (Barking Detective Mystery #2)
- Murder Your Darlings–J.J. Murphy (Algonquin Round Table Mystery #1)
- You Might as Well Die–J.J. Murphy (Algonquin Round Table Mystery #2)
- A Friendly Game of Murder–J.J. Murphy (Algonquin Round Table Mystery #3)
- Fever–Mary Beth Keane
- Leaving Everything Most Loved–Jacqueline Winspear (Maisie Dobbs Mystery #10)
- The Sleeping Salesman Enquiry–Ann Purser (Ivy Beasley Mystery #4)
- Gluten for Punishment–Nancy J. Parra (Baker’s Treat Mystery #1)
- Revenge Wears Prada–Lauren Weisberger (Prada #2)
July 2013:
- The Bookman’s Tale–Charlie Lovett
- Flappers, Flasks and Foul Play–Ellen Mansoor Collier (Jazz Age Mystery #1)
- Bathing Beauties, Booze and Bullets–Ellen Mansoor Collier (Jazz Age Mystery #2)
- The Crown–Nancy Bilyeau (Joanna Stafford #1)
- The Chalice–Nancy Bilyeau (Joanna Stafford #2)
- The House of Special Purpose–John Boyne
- In Defense of the Queen–Michelle Diener (Susanna Horenbout and John Parker #3)
- Imperial Scandal–Teresa Grant (Suzanne and Malcolm Rannoch Mystery #2)
- The Paris Affair–Teresa Grant (Suzanne and Malcolm Rannoch Mystery #3)
- The Anatomy of Death–Felicity Young (Doctor Dody McCleland Mystery #1)
August 2013:
- Antidote to Murder–Felicity Young (Doctor Dody McCleland Mystery #2)
- Murder as a Fine Art–David Morrell
- Mayhem at the Orient Express–Kylie Logan (League of Literary Ladies Mystery #1)
- Pall in the Family–Dawn Eastman (Family Fortune Mystery #1)
- The White Princess–Philippa Gregory (Cousins’ War #5)
- Sidney Chambers and the Peril of the Night–James Runcie (Grantchester Mystery #2)
- The Begonia Bribe–Alyse Carlson (Garden Society Mystery #2)
- Midnight at Marble Arch–Anne (Charlotte and Thomas Pitt Mystery #28)
- The Passion of the Purple Plumeria–Lauren Willig (Pink Carnation #10)
- The Black Country–Alex Grecian (Murder Squad #2)
- The Haunting of Maddy Clare–Simone St. James
- Z: A Novel of Zelda Fitzgerald–Therese Anne Fowler
September 2013:
- Final Sentence–Daryl Wood Gerber (Cookbook Nook Mystery #1)
- Not the Killing Type–Lorna Barrett (Booktown Mystery #7)
- Bran New Death–Victoria Hamilton (Merry Muffin Mystery #1)
- The Mysterious Death of Miss Jane Austen–Lindsay Ashford
- Dark Waters–Robin Blake (Cragg and Fidelis Mystery #2)
- A Duty to the Dead–Charles Todd (Bess Crawford Mystery #1)
- An Impartial Witness–Charles Todd (Bess Crawford Mystery #2)
- A Bitter Truth–Charles Todd (Bess Crawford Mystery #3)
- An Unmarked Grave–Charles Todd (Bess Crawford Mystery #4)
- Chili Con Carnage–Kylie Logan (Chili Cook-Off Mystery #1)
- Grace Takes Off–Julie Hyzy (Manor House Mystery #4)
October 2013:
- An Old Betrayal–Charles Finch (Charles Lenox Mystery #7)
- Winter at Death’s Hotel–Kenneth Cameron
- Murder at Hatfield House–Amanda Carmack (Elizabethan Mystery #1)
- Blind Justice–Anne Perry (William Monk Mystery #19)
- Of Grave Concern–Max McCoy (Ophelia Wylde Paranormal Mystery #1)
- Clammed Up–Barbara Ross (Maine Clambake Mystery #1)
- Heirs and Graces–Rhys Bowen (Royal Spyness Mystery #7)
- Behind the Shattered Glass–Tasha Alexander (Lady Emily Ashton Mystery #8)
- A Skeleton in the Family–Leigh Perry (Family Skeleton Mystery #1)
- Murder on the Rocks–Allyson K. Abbott (Mack’s Bar Mystery #1)
- A Question of Honor–Charles Todd (Bess Crawford Mystery #5)
- Cloche and Dagger–Jenn McKinlay (Hat Shop Mystery #1)
November 2013:
- Lady of Passion–Freda Lightfoot
- Murder, Plain and Simple–Isabella Alan (Amish Quilt Shop Mystery #1)
- Sacred Treason–James Forrester (Clarenceux Trilogy #1)
- The Roots of Betrayal–James Forrester (Clarenceux Trilogy #2)
- Drizzled with Death–Jessie Crockett (Sugar Grove Mystery #1)
- Burial Rites–Hannah Kent
- Roses Have Thorns–Sandra Byrd (Ladies in Waiting #3)
- Do or Diner–Christine Wenger (Comfort Food Mystery #1)
- Fear in the Sunlight–Nicola Upson (Josephine Tey Mystery #4)
- Longbourn–Jo Baker
- Curtsies & Conspiracies–Gail Carriger (Finishing School #2)
- Soulless–Gail Carriger (Parasol Protectorate #1)
- Changeless–Gail Carriger (Parasol Protectorate #2)
December 2013:
- Blameless–Gail Carriger (Parasol Protectorate #3)
- Heartless–Gail Carriger (Parasol Protectorate #4)
- Timeless–Gail Carriger (Parasol Protectorate #5)
- A Spear of Summer Grass–Deanna Raybourn
- The Spook Lights Affair–Marcia Muller and Bill Pronzini (Carpenter and Quincannon Mystery #2)
- Delia’s Shadow–Jaime Lee Moyer (Delia’s Shadow #1)
- Cinders & Sapphires–Leila Rasheed (At Somerton #1)
- The Vanishing–Wendy Webb
- The Mystery of Mercy Close–Marian Keyes (Walsh Family #5)
- Bewitched, Bothered and Biscotti–Bailey Cates (Magical Bakery Mystery #2)
- Charms and Chocolate Chips–Bailey Cates (Magical Bakery Mystery #3)